Silicone vs Water Based Lube: Best Lube for Anal Sex

What are silicone lubricants?

Silicone lubricants are the superior option in terms of both slickness and endurance because it doesn’t evaporate or absorb into the skin. Because it doesn’t contain glycerin, there’s no risk of causing anal cell changes or altering the microbiome. When it comes to silicone vs water-based lubes, they’re both safe for use with all types of condoms, as well as glass and metal dilators and, when you’re ready, other silicone-friendly toys. Silicone lube is waterproof, which makes it great for use in the shower, but this also means it can stain, so you’ll want to set aside some “play” sheets and towels, and pull them out when you’re ready for sex and for cleaning up afterward.

Pros and cons of silicone lubes

• Pros:
  • Longevity and endurance
  • Slipperiness
  • Versatility
  • Suitability for sensitive skin (it’s hypoallergenic, fragrance free, and taste free)
  • Can be used underwater (for shower and pool play)
  • Compatible with glass and metal toys, as well as condoms
• Cons:
  • Not compatible with silicone and PVC toysPotentially messy and hard to remove from surfaces (however, the Future Method Butt & Body Acne Scrub was developed to quickly and easily remove silicone lube from the body)
  • Stains fabrics, which means having to use towels and sex sheets

What are water-based lubricants?

Water-based lubricants are great choices because they’re condom-safe and toy-friendly, meaning the lube won’t break down the materials from which they’re made and is better for safe sex. It’s also easy to wash off and doesn’t stain. However, they aren’t a great option for anal play because they tend to dry out pretty quickly and get sticky. Secondly, most water-based lubricants contain glycerin. Glycerin is the key ingredient that makes a water-based lubricant slick, which is fabulous for providing moisture and frictionless contact (more along the lines of silicone). However, it also makes the product hyperosmolar, which can be irritating and even encourage injuries because it causes changes in the anal microbiome, weakening the cells within the rectum.

Pros and cons of water-based lubes

• Pros:
  • Compatible with condoms and toys made out of any material, including silicone
  • Easy to cleanup (washes off with soap and water)
  • Widely available
• Cons:
  • Does not maintain the lubricity and endurance that is required for anal play (better suited for vaginal sex)
  • Dries out quickly and gets sticky, which means constant reapplication
  • Some contain unpleasant tastes and odors
  • Not compatible with water, which make it a bad choice for shower and pool sex

Choosing between silicone vs water-based lubes for your needs

Anal Masturbation:

While people can use any lube for anal masturbation, if it’s a match up of silicone vs water-based lube, our preferred choice is silicone or hybrid-silicone lube because of its slickness and longevity. If you’re using fingers, either will do, including water-based, but if you’re introducing toys, you’ll want to consider a toy-safe option that’s specific to the material you’re using. Another thing to consider is where you’re playing. For example, if you’re masturbating in the bath, shower, or another wet location, water-based and hybrid lube will wash away as soon as it comes into contact with water.

Rimming:

Rimming is the one activity where using spit as lube is acceptable. Most non-silicone lubes contain scents or tastes that aren’t palatable. However, you could opt for a flavored lube to help enhance the experience. But if you’re licking a freshly-showered booty, going all natural is perfectly fine.

Foreplay:

Foreplay is the perfect way to relax, connect with your partner(s), and get in the mood for what’s to come. Silicone lubes, in particular, can feel absolutely divine when used externally as a massage oil. Just be careful: they can stain sheets and surfaces. They are also a great choice when incorporating glass toys into foreplay because this will help pre-dilate and pre-lubricate the anal canal without having to switch lubes when you’re ready to transition into anal sex.

Toys:

When it comes to toy play, water-based lubricants are a go-to favorite—and for good reason! Water-based lubes are compatible with all types of toys, and they’re easy to clean up and often made with all-natural ingredients.

If you’re looking to level up, hybrid lubes (a mix of water and silicone) offer the best of both worlds with enhanced lubrication and that irresistible slippery feel.

Fortunately, if you’re using glass toys, like the Future Method Glass Anal Dilator Set, you can – and should – use silicone lube. It offers maximum slip, so when you’re ready to make the switch to the real thing, there’s no need to change a thing. From start to finish, you’ll feel the difference.

Anal sex:

When it comes to anal sex, lube isn’t optional—it’s essential. Real lube (not spit!) is the key to a smooth, pleasurable experience. Foreplay helps pre-lubricate the anal canal, but since the anus doesn’t self-lubricate like the vagina, adding plenty of lube is crucial for comfort and safety. From a medical perspective, looking at silicone vs water-based lube, silicone lube is the top choice for anal play, with or without condoms. Its unmatched slickness and endurance ensure a seamless ride.

Silicone lubes are latex-friendly, hypoallergenic, and waterproof, making them great for sensitive skin and shower play alike. Just keep in mind that silicone lube can stain sheets and requires a bit more cleanup—but our specially formulated scrub makes post-play care a breeze.

While tempting, warming, cooling, or desensitizing lubes should be avoided for anal play. They can irritate or mask pain, increasing the risk of injuries like tears or hemorrhoids. Instead, consider exploring our anal stretching guide to properly prepare and ensure a safer, more comfortable experience.

Ultimately, finding the right lube is all about what works best for you, your partner, and your body.

Fisting:

Fisting is an extreme sport and requires special lube. Most people turn to something called J-lube, which was actually originally developed as an obstetrical lubricant in veterinary clinics. It’s a water-based lube that has become incredibly popular within the anal community (and porn stars) for a number of reasons. When mixed with water, the concentrated powder becomes a gel-like substance that’s especially good for larger toys and fisting, not only for its slick qualities but also because you can make gallons of product from one 10 oz bottle. It’s thick, coats well, and lasts long.

Conclusion

Choosing the right lubricant is key to a safe, comfortable, and pleasurable ride. Whether you prefer the long-lasting slickness of silicone, the versatility of water-based options, or the best of both worlds with hybrids, your choice should align with your personal preferences, compatibility with toys and condoms, and your specific needs. By understanding the pros and cons of each type and avoiding harmful options like desensitizing or irritating formulas, you can make informed decisions that prioritize your health and enjoyment. Take your time to experiment, find what works best for you, and remember—great lube is the foundation of great play!